Asset Classes5 分で読めます

Cyclical Stocks vs. Defensive Stocks

Even in a recession, people use electricity and eat meals. But they put off a new car or an overseas trip. This simple difference divides stocks into two groups.

Stocks that run with the economy, stocks that hold on

A cyclical stock is stock in a company whose profits swing greatly with the economic cycle. It earns well when people open their wallets and shrinks sharply when they're anxious.

A defensive stock is stock in a company whose earnings are relatively steady whether the economy is good or bad. These are companies that sell things we keep consuming no matter the situation.

The key is the question 'will I keep buying this company's products even in a recession?' If the answer is 'I can put it off,' it's closer to a cyclical stock; if 'I can't put it off,' closer to a defensive stock.

Which industries belong where

Cyclical industries: consumer discretionary (autos, luxury goods, travel, hotels, airlines, dining out), financials, industrials, energy, mining, and so on. These are areas where consumption and investment increase only when the economy is good.

Defensive industries: utilities (electricity, gas, water), consumer staples (food, household goods), healthcare, telecom, and so on. These handle essentials that are hard to cut even in a recession.

For example, autos, cruise lines, and department stores are often classified as cyclical stocks, while electric utilities, household-goods makers (e.g., P&G), and food companies are often classified as defensive stocks.

The volatility difference seen through beta

This difference also shows up in a number called 'beta.' Beta is a metric indicating how much a stock moves when the entire market moves by 1.

Cyclical stocks usually have a beta greater than 1 (roughly 1.1–1.3). They rise more than the market and fall more than the market.

Defensive stocks usually have a beta less than 1 (roughly 0.5–0.8). Even when the market churns, they are relatively less shaken.

So in a downturn, cyclical stocks fall faster and deeper than the market, while defensive stocks tend to fall less or sometimes hold on.

The beta ranges are rough values that vary by source and period. A specific stock's beta changes over time, and even a defensive stock can fall along with a major crisis.

Why this distinction is useful

Knowing this distinction lets you understand why your portfolio moves the way it does.

If you're concentrated in cyclical stocks, you may be thrilled in a boom, but in a downturn you may have to endure a bigger drawdown than others. If you're mostly in defensive stocks, you may be relatively bored in a bull market, but your mind may be less shaken in a bear market.

Neither side is 'the answer.' But holding assets while knowing what kind of risk you can bear and how much reduces the mistake of panic-selling at the bottom.

よくある質問

Q. Do defensive stocks not lose money?

No. Defensive stocks merely 'tend to be less shaken'; they don't fail to fall. In big financial crises, defensive stocks fell too, and in many cases their recovery speed was only relatively better. 'Defensive' should be understood to mean 'relatively low volatility,' not 'no losses.'

Q. Can't I just look at the current economy and switch stocks?

It's easy to say but hard to do in practice. Accurately calling the timing of an economic turn in advance is difficult even for experts, and frequent trading magnifies fees, taxes, and timing mistakes. This concept is safer used as 'a tool for understanding the risk character of your portfolio' than as 'an economic-forecasting tool.'